Local News

July 2, 2013

State Supreme Court decision could mean new trial for Whitfield man

A Whitfield County man convicted of identity fraud for stealing a woman’s bank card to go on a $1,000 shopping spree at Walnut Square Mall in 2009 will have his case reviewed after the state Supreme Court on Monday said the appeals court misapplied the law.

In May 2010, a Whitfield County jury found Todd Christopher McNair guilty of identity fraud. The court sentenced him to five years in prison plus five on probation. The charge carries up to 10 years in prison or up to $100,000 in fines. McNair’s attorney, Public Defender Mike McCarthy, argued that under the “rule of lenity” McNair should be sentenced instead for financial transaction card theft, which carries up to three years in prison or up to $5,000 in fines.

According to a summary prepared by a Supreme Court information officer, Black’s Law Dictionary defines the “rule of lenity” as a “judicial doctrine requiring that when a court is faced with an ambiguous criminal statute that sets out multiple or inconsistent punishments, it must favor the more lenient punishment.”

The Supreme Court on Monday remanded the case back to the appeals court for review. Justice Robert Benham wrote that the appeals court has incorrectly ruled several times “that the rule of lenity does not apply when the differing punishments are all felony-level. ... This court has never held, however, that the rule of lenity only applies when the punishments are as between a misdemeanor and a felony.”

McCarthy said the Supreme Court’s ruling could affect the outcome of other cases in which lenity is an issue.

“We have several cases that have been waiting for this decision to come because they involve the same issue right here in Dalton,” he said. “Now that we’ve gotten this decision, which we’re very happy about, we’ll be able to go forward on these cases.”

The ruling doesn’t automatically mean McNair will be re-sentenced on a lesser charge. District Attorney Bert Poston said prosecutors will argue that even if the rule applies, the facts show McNair still should have been convicted of the more stringent charge.

“If we prevail, the conviction will stand as is,” Poston said. “If, however, the Court of Appeals believes that the jury should have had the option to convict on the lesser charge, the entire conviction will be set aside, and McNair will get a new trial.”

This isn’t the first time McNair has had a case before the Supreme Court. In 2007, McNair was arrested in Dalton and charged with DUI, obstruction of an officer and making an improper left turn. A jury in March 2008 found him not guilty of DUI and obstruction, but they convicted him on the turning violation for pulling into the outermost lane rather than the innermost lane.

He appealed to the Supreme Court, which unanimously ruled in 2009 that Georgia’s left turn law was vague and unconstitutional.

1
Text Only
Local News
  • Kiwanis Club3.jpg Kiwanians get a lesson in money and banking

    Money.
    It makes it easier for us to buy and sell goods and services. It is the measure by which we judge the relative value of those goods and services, and it allows us to “store value,” by placing it away and using it when we need it.

    July 28, 2014 1 Photo

  • Sheriff: Inmates don’t ask to vote

    In his 21 years of service, Whitfield County Sheriff Scott Chitwood said inmates have never asked for the opportunity to vote.

    July 28, 2014

  • Little library 1 mlh.jpg Little Libraries, big goal

    Whitfield County just received a new library.
    And better yet, 26 more are on the way to the region.

    July 27, 2014 1 Photo

  • Picture 3.jpg Rock solid

    A great number of things have come and gone since 1974.
    One that hasn’t: a small Dalton school founded by parents wanting a unique learning environment for their children.

    July 27, 2014 2 Photos

  • Vann House Day '14 6 mlh.jpg History comes alive at Vann House

    SPRING PLACE — In the early 1800s, the 1,000-acre plantation belonging to Cherokee Indian leader James Vann was a bustling place.

    July 26, 2014 5 Photos

  • Local officials agree with Deal

    Regarding news last week that approximately 30 unaccompanied minors from Central America, who had crossed the southern border into the United States, were sent without warning to Dalton last year and enrolled in Dalton Public Schools, Republican politicians representing portions of Murray and Whitfield Counties agree — state and local school officials deserved to know in advance, they say.

    July 26, 2014

  • Former chamber location 2 mlh.jpg Plan could cut flooding, stormwater damage in Dalton

    On a recent day, McClellan Creek flowed gently through Harlan Godfrey Civitan Park. But some park goers who live near the area say that even a mild rain can turn the creek into a torrent that eats away at their property.

    July 26, 2014 1 Photo

  • Civil War anniversary: The Battle of Crow Valley, May 9-12, 1864

    The Atlanta Campaign began during the first two weeks of May 1864 in and around Dalton. Union Maj. Gen. William T. Sherman’s strategy was to target two of his armies, about 80,000 men, against Confederate Gen. Joseph E. Johnston’s Army of Tennessee at Dalton. Then, while Johnston’s attention was diverted by these forces, he would secretly send his third army, about 25,000 troops under Maj. Gen. James B. McPherson, in a flanking movement to the southwest through Snake Creek Gap. Sherman’s goal was to break Johnston’s railroad supply line some 15 miles south at Resaca and trap Johnston’s Confederates in Dalton.

    July 26, 2014

  • New church being  built mlh.jpg Church construction continues

    July 25, 2014 1 Photo

  • Avans.jpg Three arrested in arson plot to claim insurance money

    Three people have been arrested for their role in a fire at a Chatsworth home as part of an insurance scam to collect money, officials said.

    July 25, 2014 3 Photos