Local News

July 1, 2012

Supreme Court immigration ruling unlikely to affect Georgia law

Last week’s U.S. Supreme Court decision on Arizona’s immigration law appears to have no direct impact on the immigration law passed by Georgia legislators last year that went into effect one year ago today, local observers say.

The Georgia law has been challenged as unconstitutional by the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) and other groups, but the 11th Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals had put the lawsuit on hold while waiting for the Supreme Court decision on the Arizona law. The appellate court last week asked lawyers on both sides to submit briefs by Friday, July 6, stating how they believe the Supreme Court decision affects Georgia law.

“It seems to be the general consensus so far that the (Supreme Court) decision won’t have much impact (on Georgia) in that the provisions that were declared to be unconstitutional or in conflict with federal law are not part of what Georgia passed,” said state Sen. Charlie Bethel, R-Dalton.

The Supreme Court stuck down a provision of the Arizona law that made it a misdemeanor for an illegal alien to seek employment, another provision that allowed police to arrest without a warrant those they suspected of being illegal aliens and a third provision requiring aliens to carry registration papers. That final provision is part of federal law.

None of those provisions are in the Georgia law.

But the court in an 8-0 ruling said it would not strike down a provision of the Arizona law requiring police to try to check the immigration status of people they detain or arrest if they reasonably suspect they are illegal aliens. Supreme Court Justice Elena Kagan did not take part in the case. Before joining the court, Kagan served as solicitor general in the Obama administration and took part in its initial challenge to the Arizona law.

Georgia’s law does have a similar requirement to that provision. It gives police the authority to check the immigration status of someone they detain or arrest if they reasonably suspect that person is an illegal alien. The 11th Circuit court put that provision on hold until the Supreme Court ruled on Arizona’s law. But the Supreme Court indicated it might entertain another challenge to that provision of the Arizona law.

“It’s not that they said ‘You have 100 percent backing to go ahead and check people to make sure they are in the country legally.’ What they said was ‘We don’t have an actual case where somebody claims they have been racially profiled,’” said Matthew Hipps, assistant professor of political science at Dalton State College.

Several observers said they don’t believe it will be long before the court has such a challenge.

“It’s almost like they said they anticipate there will be problems with that provision,” said Ken Ellinger, associate professor of political science at Dalton State College. “It seems like an invitation to racial profiling, but they aren’t willing to strike it down before it takes effect. Somebody’s certainly going to sue, probably sooner rather than later.”

But Hipps said unless the Supreme Court does make a definitive ruling on the issue the 11th Circuit is unlikely to strike down the provision of Georgia’s law allowing police to check the immigration status of people they detain or arrest.

Georgia’s law also contains a provision forcing employers to use the federal E-Verify program to determine whether new hires have the government’s permission to work in the United States. The Supreme Court upheld a separate Arizona law last year that forced employers to use the E-Verify program.

Text Only
Local News
  • runner thompson.jpg Taking the race back

    Dean Thompson didn’t go 100 yards in his 26.2 miles through the streets of Boston without seeing people on the side of the road cheering for him.

    April 23, 2014 1 Photo

  • Bobby Lee Dixon mg.jpg Officials: Man jailed for driving toward officer

    A Chatsworth man who officials said accelerated a vehicle toward a law enforcement officer who was approaching on foot remains in the Murray County jail without bond.

    April 23, 2014 2 Photos

  • Standoff 1 mlh.jpg Charges undetermined following standoff (Updated 5:45 p.m.)

    Police have yet to decide whether to press criminal charges against a man they say was armed and intoxicated while barricading himself in his office at a carpet mill in downtown Dalton Tuesday evening.

    April 23, 2014 1 Photo 1 Story

  • Man charged for using fraudulent Social Security card

    A man is being held in the Whitfield County Jail on multiple charges for using a fraudulent Social Security card with someone else’s Social Security number to land a job at a rug manufacturer in Dalton and for providing false information to receive workers’ compensation benefits, according to the Georgia State Board of Workers’ Compensation’s Enforcement Division.

    April 23, 2014

  • Standoff 1 mlh.jpg Police: Four-hour standoff ends with peaceful surrender

    A man who was armed with at least one firearm and believed to be under the influence of alcohol surrendered to police Tuesday night after barricading himself for four hours inside a carpet mill in downtown Dalton, officials said.

    April 23, 2014 2 Photos

  • Murray deputy bit by drug dog while taking selfie

    A Murray County Sheriff’s Office deputy is recovering after one of the department’s drug dogs bit him in the face on Monday.

    April 23, 2014

  • Local wrestler ‘made everybody smile’

    Rash Renegade got his wrestling nickname after a motorcycle wreck several years ago left him with a bad case of road burn.

    April 23, 2014

  • Pinwheels in murray '14 1 mlh.jpg Awareness can prevent child abuse

    Three hundred forty-six pinwheels dotted the Murray County Courthouse lawn on Tuesday, representing 346 reported cases of child abuse in the county last year.

    April 23, 2014 2 Photos

  • Murray library, regional system still far apart

    Murray County officials say they will announce soon if they will follow through with their plan to take the Chatsworth-Murray Library out of the Northwest Georgia Regional Library System.

    April 22, 2014

  • Fire believed to have started outside home

    Investigators are still working to learn what sparked a fire that nearly destroyed a house at 602 Top St. in Dalton on Monday.

    April 22, 2014