Local News

February 20, 2014

Werner Braun: Toxicity vs. hazardous substances

As a chemist and toxicologist back in the day, I have a pretty good understanding of the difference between a substance which contains toxins but does not pose a health risk and a toxin-containing substance that should be considered hazardous.

I’ve noticed over the years that the definitions of toxicity and hazard are frequently confused, both in popular understanding and — more critically — among government regulators. This last fact can have dramatic impacts on policy decisions.

Here’s the critical point: Not everything that’s toxic should be considered hazardous. Unfortunately, some folks seem, either willingly or unwittingly, to create anxiety among the public by equating toxicity and risk. Clearly they are not the same.

Products that contain toxins are all around us, and used properly, present no hazard. Take for example a household cleaning agent containing chlorine bleach. When used as recommended, chlorine bleach is an effective cleaning agent that brightens clothes and diminishes stains. In our laundry rooms, this chemical doesn’t normally present a risk to those who use it.

However, if you were to ingest even a little bit of chlorine bleach you would likely die.

Let’s look at a more innocuous example, H2O, or water. Water is an element necessary for life, something which we use on a daily basis for drinking, cooking and bathing. Nothing could be better for us, right? Nothing could be less toxic? That’s certainly correct in most cases. However, if you got enough water in your lungs — as in a drowning accident — you would most likely die.

So, even the most helpful substances can become hazardous under the “right,” or wrong, conditions.

This comes to my mind because of recent concerns raised by the environmental community concerning coal fly ash.

For those who aren’t familiar with coal fly ash, it’s basically a component of the generation of electricity made from coal. It’s the small, light material that goes up with the flue gas when you burn coal to make electricity. Looking at it under a microscope, coal fly ash is essentially small glass beads. As such, these glass beads are inert.

Currently, coal fly ash is being “captured” at coal-fired power plants and is reused in the production of materials designed for the building industry, such as cement, bricks, gypsum board and carpet backing. This process provides a way to recycle and reuse waste that would otherwise be sent to landfills or impoundments.

Some members of the environmental community believe that because coal ash can present environmental problems under the wrong circumstances that it shouldn’t be used in certain building products or any of a number of other uses for which it is currently approved by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. They believe it should be labeled hazardous.

Why is there a concern?

Around five or six years ago, some impounded coal ash was accidentally released into a stream when an earthen dam failed, causing environmental damage for many downstream residents.

That was definitely a problem, as I know we’d all agree. But that event generated a movement to regulate coal fly ash and to label it as a hazardous substance.

It’s very clear that the answer isn’t to ban the use of coal fly ash altogether, or to reclassify it as a hazardous substance, but rather to regulate coal ash impoundment appropriately so this type of accident won’t happen again.

But to label coal fly ash as a hazardous material is simply overkill. Period.

We certainly want to understand what toxins are around us, but environmental regulations must be based on regulating hazard. Remember this important point: Toxicity does not in and of itself equate to hazard. We can’t allow ourselves to become solely focused on whether or not something is “toxic.” The real issue is “Is it hazardous?”

Focusing on toxicity casts an enormously broad net over an issue for which an enormously broad net is not needed.

Clearly, we need to regulate hazardous materials and to make sure that they don’t become threats to the general public. But we need to use some common sense along the way.

Werner Braun is president of the Dalton-based Carpet and Rug Institute.

 

1
Text Only
Local News
  • runner thompson.jpg Taking the race back

    Dean Thompson didn’t go 100 yards in his 26.2 miles through the streets of Boston without seeing people on the side of the road cheering for him.

    April 23, 2014 1 Photo

  • Bobby Lee Dixon mg.jpg Officials: Man jailed for driving toward officer

    A Chatsworth man who officials said accelerated a vehicle toward a law enforcement officer who was approaching on foot remains in the Murray County jail without bond.

    April 23, 2014 2 Photos

  • Standoff 1 mlh.jpg Charges undetermined following standoff (Updated 5:45 p.m.)

    Police have yet to decide whether to press criminal charges against a man they say was armed and intoxicated while barricading himself in his office at a carpet mill in downtown Dalton Tuesday evening.

    April 23, 2014 1 Photo 1 Story

  • Man charged for using fraudulent Social Security card

    A man is being held in the Whitfield County Jail on multiple charges for using a fraudulent Social Security card with someone else’s Social Security number to land a job at a rug manufacturer in Dalton and for providing false information to receive workers’ compensation benefits, according to the Georgia State Board of Workers’ Compensation’s Enforcement Division.

    April 23, 2014

  • Standoff 1 mlh.jpg Police: Four-hour standoff ends with peaceful surrender

    A man who was armed with at least one firearm and believed to be under the influence of alcohol surrendered to police Tuesday night after barricading himself for four hours inside a carpet mill in downtown Dalton, officials said.

    April 23, 2014 2 Photos

  • Murray deputy bit by drug dog while taking selfie

    A Murray County Sheriff’s Office deputy is recovering after one of the department’s drug dogs bit him in the face on Monday.

    April 23, 2014

  • Local wrestler ‘made everybody smile’

    Rash Renegade got his wrestling nickname after a motorcycle wreck several years ago left him with a bad case of road burn.

    April 23, 2014

  • Pinwheels in murray '14 1 mlh.jpg Awareness can prevent child abuse

    Three hundred forty-six pinwheels dotted the Murray County Courthouse lawn on Tuesday, representing 346 reported cases of child abuse in the county last year.

    April 23, 2014 2 Photos

  • Murray library, regional system still far apart

    Murray County officials say they will announce soon if they will follow through with their plan to take the Chatsworth-Murray Library out of the Northwest Georgia Regional Library System.

    April 22, 2014

  • Fire believed to have started outside home

    Investigators are still working to learn what sparked a fire that nearly destroyed a house at 602 Top St. in Dalton on Monday.

    April 22, 2014