As I thought about how best to describe the upcoming vote on Amendment No. 1, the so-called “charter school amendment” that will appear on the Nov. 6 ballot, it occurred to me that it should be called the “T-SPLOST for Education” vote.
We all remember that summer referendum and how it ended, and this ballot initiative is just like that one in that it is (1) brought to us by the same General Assembly that gave us the T-SPLOST; and (2) favored on the “yes” side by big money companies and organizations. The similarities are almost eerie.
The real problem that I see, though, is the misinformation being used and the half-truths being told to get this monstrosity passed. Supporters would have you believe that charter schools, which are supposed to be “laboratories of innovation” and operate free of many of the rules and regulations that hamstring traditional public schools, are somehow in danger of becoming extinct. They fail to tell you that, under current law, local boards can already approve charter schools in local communities (more than 100 already exist), and the State Board of Education can already approve such schools over the objections of local boards of education (15 of these already exist.).
In Georgia, current law permits entire school systems to gain charter status, freeing them from having to comply with onerous laws and rules and do what is best for children.
Proponents of the amendment would have you believe this is about “school choice.” I wonder just how much “choice” would satisfy some of them, for in addition to the choices I outlined in the previous paragraph, we have many systems that offer in-system school choice as well as opportunities for children to cross school system lines and attend their schools. We have home schools, we have private schools, we have religious schools, etc. Do we really need still another layer?
Finally, I’ve heard amendment supporters present the bogus argument that this will actually “save” money for local school systems when charter schools open in a community and some students leave the local public schools for the charter school. The argument against that theory takes a bit of explaining, but I’d say folks would have to be pretty naïve to fail to grasp the reality that opening a new school (a new “cost center,” if you will) would somehow cost the taxpayers less than operating just the schools already in existence.
It is about money and power, though, and to no small extent. Money that would go from taxpayers’ pockets to the coffers of large corporations that make millions running charter schools in Georgia and all over the country, and money in the campaign funds of lawmakers who support these efforts.
The power to decide whether charter schools are appropriate in local communities made by a faceless group of political appointees in Atlanta rather than by the duly elected local officials who should, in my opinion, be making such decisions.
My vote will be “No” on Amendment No. 1 on Nov. 6.
Herb Garrett is the executive director of the Georgia School Superintendents Association.
Christmas parades bring tradition of joy
It is a gift that has kept on giving for decades, and its magic will be unwrapped once more when the Dalton Noon Lions Club sponsors the annual Christmas parade downtown on Thursday.
Mark Millican: Advent can be an adventure
It’s hard to remember — did we take off last Thursday for an actual day of Thanks-giving?
Charles Oliver: Police unsuccessful in persistent drug search
David Eckert has filed a lawsuit against Deming, N.M., police, the Hidalgo County sheriff’s office, several officers from those departments and the Gila Regional Medical Center after he was forced to undergo a number of invasive medical searches.
Letter: Unwitting tools?
The t-e-a in tea party stands for “taxed enough already.” And if you are the average citizen this certainly is true.
Lee H. Hamilton: Dogged journalism is a blessing, not a curse
Let’s start with the obvious: A democracy needs intelligence agencies. It needs to know what’s happening in the world — and understand the plans of allies and enemies — to keep the nation prepared and secure.
Guild event honors local heroes
When we were younger, many of us played at being Batman or Superman or Captain Marvel. These caped comic book superheroes inspired many of us.
Citizens of the Week: Providence Ministries’ holiday volunteers
For more than 20 years, Providence Ministries has fed the hungry in the Dalton area. And it has helped make sure that even the neediest have the sort of full holiday meals that most of us take for granted.
Mark Millican: Thankful? Yes!
A case could be made Thanksgiving has become just another day on the sales calendar, a prelude to Christmas signaling ’tis the season to buy, buy, buy.
Letter: Good intentions aren’t enough
As I read the article in the Sunday Daily Citizen I found it very disturbing.
Kettle campaign needs your help
You’ve seen them for the past couple of weeks now, bright red kettles staffed by Salvation Army and volunteer bell ringers, stationed at grocery and retail stores throughout the area.
- More Opinion Headlines
- Christmas parades bring tradition of joy