Opinion

August 26, 2012

Justice denied

Murray County has a serious problem on its hands thanks to former chief magistrate Bryant Cochran.

Cochran stepped down recently after admitting that he pre-signed warrants for law enforcement officers.

The Georgia Judicial Qualifications Commission was investigating those actions along with allegations that Cochran made inappropriate sexual advances towards 36-year-old Angela Garmley of Chatsworth. Cochran’s resignation blocked the commission from holding formal hearings on those matters. But he may still face criminal charges. District Attorney Bert Poston has asked the Georgia Bureau of Investigation (GBI) to look into the matter.

If Cochran had read the U.S. Constitution he would find the Fourth Amendment guarantees that “the right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.”

The role of a judge is to determine whether law enforcement has probable cause before granting officers any warrant. As a judge and a former law enforcement officer himself, Cochran should have known this.

By pre-signing warrants, by not sitting in critical judgment of law enforcement before granting warrants, Cochran abrogated one of a judge’s most basic duties, denied some people one of their most basic rights and dealt a blow to our legal system.

And he may have dealt a huge blow to Murray County. Each person who was arrested or convicted based on one of those pre-signed warrants can likely demand a new trial, with the evidence collected under that warrant thrown out. And those persons may have a strong claim against the county for false arrest.

Yes, the county has insurance that may cover any civil suits filed by those individuals. Taxpayers may not have to pay the judgments in those lawsuits. But they’ll pay in the end through higher premiums.

In a statement when he resigned, Cochran accepted full responsibility for pre-signing warrants. But he doesn’t bear the full responsibility. Each law enforcement officer who accepted one of those warrants and filled it out knew that was illegal. And they did it anyway.

We do not yet know how many officers were involved or how long this was going on. But it’s difficult to believe it could have gone on for very long or involved more than one officer without others in the Murray County law enforcement community knowing about it.

Any officer, any court official, any elected official who knew about those warrants and didn’t speak out is just as responsible for them as those officers who used those warrants. They have a duty to enforce the law and uphold the Constitution and they failed to do that. They have a responsibility to speak out now and help the GBI investigation.

 

1
Text Only
Opinion
  • Move carefully, but soon

    No one intended for it to happen. No one had any bad motives.
    But during a period of 40 years or more, quite a few people didn’t do enough planning, didn’t have enough foresight to see what all of the development in Dalton would do.

    July 27, 2014

  • Local school systems must bear costs of federal immigration failure

    No word. No warning. Little help.
    That’s what Dalton Public Schools officials received from the federal government when it dropped 30 Central American students into local classrooms last school year.

    July 26, 2014

  • Sacrifices worth honoring

    Members of the Dalton City Council were recently approached by representatives of the local chapter of the Military Order of the Purple Heart with a request to declare Dalton a Purple Heart City. Council members indicated they will approve the request.

    July 24, 2014

  • We must do better

    The numbers tell a sad tale.
    Registered voters: 36,843.
    Cards cast: 5,307.
    That means the turnout for Tuesday’s runoffs in Whitfield County was a measly 14.4 percent, according to unofficial results from the Whitfield County elections office.

    July 23, 2014

  • Letter: Control immigration

    Thousands are starting to pour into our country, and things are getting personal. Why would we end up the bad guys if we turn away children who aren’t ours? How does it make us better people to let one man steal from our children and stand by and do nothing?

    July 23, 2014

  • Helping with Book Blast betters the community

    The school test results are in, and students in Whitfield and Murray counties mostly improved from a year ago, mirroring or exceeding average scores of their peers.

    July 23, 2014

  • Mark Millican: Guns are already everywhere

    Though it happened over 30 years ago, the image is still vivid.

    July 22, 2014

  • Charles Oliver: Former officer works overtime improperly

    Stephen F. Hall has pleaded guilty to theft by deception and falsifying a government record.

    July 22, 2014

  • Dalton council should seek answers

    Judicial elections in this area are usually pretty staid. In fact, they are generally nonexistent, since most judges run unopposed.

    July 21, 2014

  • Letter: Something to think about

    It has been better than four months now since Malaysia Flight 370 went missing. During that time we have heard all kinds of speculation, conjecture and opinions as to what happened to it. The only certainties to emerge are that the Malaysians fumbled the ball early on and there are some understandably distressed loved ones left to deal with their losses.

    July 21, 2014