Sports Columns

March 25, 2014

Tom Lindley: More data, caution both needed

Youth sports teams — whether made up of boys, girls or both — face a growing problem. More young athletes are being treated for head injuries, justifiably creating a growing concern among worried parents. Their fear is compounded by a lack of reliable data and the reluctance of some young athletes to report injuries, fearing they would let down their teammates if they did.

Those are just a few observations from a report issued by the Institute of Medicine’s Committee on Sports-Related Concussions in Youth. Its chairman, Robert Graham, said “more and better data” is needed to understand what’s happening and how to make sports safer.

In recent years, press reports focused on professional football players suffering concussions following violent collisions. Those concerns have led to questions about the impact of repeated blows experienced by boys and girls from the earliest youth leagues through high school.

This much is clear: The public is taking notice, and participation is being affected. The number of participants in Pop Warner football, for instance, showed a 9.5 percent drop between 2010 and 2012, some 23,612 kids.

Some say the steep reduction could be traced to a trend of young athletes specializing in one sport, while others blame a fear of head injuries, especially among parents.

Female athletes appear no less immune to serious sports injury. Last year’s report from the committee on concussions said soccer, lacrosse and basketball are linked to the highest rates of concussions among high school and college girls. At a recent U.S. House of Representatives subcommittee hearing, it was even suggested that the youngest athletes should not play contact sports before age 15, the time when most students enter high school.

A compilation of statistics by the Southwest Athletic Trainers Association is alarming. It shows:

• About 8,000 children are treated in emergency rooms each day for sports-related injuries.

• Female high school soccer athletes suffer almost 40 percent more concussions than males. Female basketball players sustain 240 percent more concussions than their male counterparts.

• Emergency department visits for concussions sustained during organized team sports activities doubled among 8-to-13-year-olds between 1997 and 2007.

These trends could be partly explained by the growing popularity of travel team sports — basketball, baseball, softball, volleyball, lacrosse and soccer — across the country. For many kids, participation in a tournament schedule of high-level play continues throughout the year, thereby increasing the likelihood of injuries.

In its report, the Committee on Sports-Related Concussions called for an examination of “what’s known and what’s not” about young people and their sports. It called on organizations such as the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institutes of Health, NCAA and National Federation of State High School Associations to coordinate study of sports and produce a list of recommendations.

The committee favors:

• Establishing a national surveillance system to determine the rate of sports-related concussions among youth, and include data on protective equipment, as well as the causes and extent of injuries.

• Supporting research to improve concussion diagnosis and create age-specific guidelines for managing concussions.

• Conducting studies on effects of concussions and repetitive head injuries over a lifespan.

• Undertaking a scientific evaluation of the effectiveness of age-appropriate techniques, rules and playing and practice standards in reducing sports-related concussions.

• Funding research on age- and sex-related risk factors for concussions.

No doubt, research of this magnitude will take a long time to conduct and analyze. There’s also the possibility the results could be troubling, especially to traditionalists who think injuries are just part of the game.

But it also might help someone like Olympic gold medalist Briana Scurry, a former goalie for the U.S. women’s soccer team, avert head injuries like the one she suffered during a match two years ago. It left her with severe headaches, disrupted sleep, anxiety and depression.

It’s fine to encourage boys and girls to compete. It seems only fair that they also understand the risks that are involved in those activities.

Tom Lindley is a sports columnist for Community Newspaper Holdings Inc. You can write to him at

Text Only
Sports Columns