Sports

May 10, 2014

Tom Lindley: ‘Power’ players of college sports are showing it off

In case you missed it, the NCAA officially cried “Uncle” recently and handled over certain decision-making authority to officials with the five major conferences — the ones with the true power, clout and deep pockets.

The direction set in motion a process that will allow teams from the Atlantic Coast, Big Ten, Big 12, Pac-12 and Southeastern conferences to make some of their own rules. That clears the way to offer stipends to athletes in addition to traditional scholarship costs involving tuition, books and room and board.

That would seem reasonable, especially when one takes a look at how much money the 65 athletic departments in those leagues generate. Details will take time to figure out, but it will happen.

Schools that operate a rung down the competitive ladder fought against a spending plan they knew they could not afford. But realizing it was looking at a revolt, the NCAA Division I Board of Governors voted to give the power players more autonomy.

The less powerful schools face a dilemma: They don’t have the big money — most of which is generated from large crowds at football games and the huge payouts from cable networks — to offer a stipend, which some have estimated would cost between $2,000 to $4,000 per player a year. Furthermore, they’ve argued, the stipends would put them at an even worse bargaining position when recruiting against a school that can offer extra benefits to a player.

Anyone who thinks a stipend is all that’s being discussed is mistaken. That’s only the beginning. College athletes have seen the financial showers rain down on their programs and their celebrated coaches, so it won’t be long before the ante is upped.

Players know universities are making money off them through licensing agreements and the products those apply to, so what they expect out of a fair deal and what the NCAA and other college power brokers are discussing remain far apart.

The NCAA has evolved into an organization that gives every appearance that it seems unsure of its mission or if it even has one.

Mark Emmert, the president of the NCAA, gets his marching orders from the universities, the mix of schools his organization is hired to oversee. If he pushes too hard, there are repercussions; if his organization is lax, there is negative feedback.

That’s why at times the NCAA comes across as foolish and draws harsh criticism from its detractors, who see it as inconsistent in one of its main duties — rules enforcement.

Even Emmert admitted the NCAA had developed “dumb rules,” especially when determining what’s permissible and what’s not. The classic example involved a bagel, which was considered a snack (permissible), but when it was served with cream cheese it was determined to be a “meal,” which was a violation.

The burden to differentiate between a snack and a meal was left to the NCAA to decide. The interpretation, however, often resulted in making the NCAA look silly and left member schools frustrated.

The NCAA looked bad again last week when University of Michigan basketball player Mitch McGary, who played only sparingly last year, was suspended for a year after the center tested positive for drug use following a game he didn’t play in. The upshot was that McGary was forced to turn pro, although he would have been better served staying in school, which he preferred to do anyway. Oddly, because of a recent rule change, had he been tested after April 15, his suspension would have been only six months.

Did the punishment fit the crime? The NCAA saw the violation as a simple black or white matter, which it wasn’t. Once again, the NCAA showed its rigidity toward student-athletes, especially one who had an otherwise clean record.

Athletes are now demanding that someone represent their interests, their needs. Give the football players at Northwestern, one of the top academic institutions in the country, credit for driving that point home in their effort to form a union. There’s no telling how the union vote will go, and maybe it doesn’t matter, but they have made it abundantly clear they have been — and will be — heard.

If the powerful figures behind college sports listen, problems can be resolved.

If they don’t, the big battles away from the playing field are just beginning.

Tom Lindley is a sports columnist for the Community Newspaper Holdings Inc. News Service. You can write to him at tlindley@cnhi.com.

1
Text Only
Sports
  • Northwest baseball standout Pierce now at Ringgold

    Seth Pierce, a former Northwest Whitfield High School athlete and two-time Daily Citizen All-Area Baseball Player of the Year, transferred to Ringgold High School this summer, Ringgold athletic director and football coach Robert Akins confirmed Monday.

    July 28, 2014

  • SE fball conditioning 1 mlh.jpg Prep football: Raiders enter preseason hoping for breakthrough

    Entering his third year as Southeast Whitfield High School’s football coach, Sean Gray believes the last obstacle is belief.
    He believes this group of Raiders has that quality.

    July 28, 2014 2 Photos

  • Devin Golden: Other sports start practice this week

    Football isn’t the only high school sport during the fall — and the others are joining in this week.

    July 28, 2014

  • Three locals on NW team in state golf event

    Three local golfers — Hardin Chambless, Tori Owens and Landon Painter — played Sunday in round one of the Junior Sectional Challenge Match.

    July 28, 2014

  • DHS fball condition#1C0E6F8.jpg Prep football: Dalton enters camp well ahead of learning curve

    The joke came quick to the lips of Dalton High School football coach Matt Land when asked how the opening day of conditioning for the Catamounts went on Friday.
    “We can quit and go home,” Land said. “They have it all figured out.”

    July 27, 2014 1 Photo

  • Hall of Fame Baseball_Chan.jpg Making a trip into town

    Frank Thomas was always driven to excel, and that sure served him well.
    “I was never that blue-chip prospect,” he said. “I had to outwork my opponents.”

    July 27, 2014 1 Photo

  • Hall of Fame Baseball_Chan2.jpg Chris Whitfield: Memories stay with us, and go with them

    I still remember the pandemonium that broke out in the dorm at Middle Georgia College in tiny Cochran, Ga., the night of “The Slide” in the 1992 National League Championship Series. It was a fire drill, wall street-buying frenzy and a Roman toga party all in one.

    July 27, 2014 1 Photo

  • Deshawn Ruffin Sign#1C0E79A.jpg Dalton State College signs PG from Florida

    Dalton State College announced signing a Jacksonville, Fla., prep basketball standout to its men’s basketball team.

    July 27, 2014 1 Photo

  • DHS vs RHS fball xtra 7 mlh.jpg Totally focused on fútbol

    In order to chase his soccer dream and continue to mature and improve in the sport that he loves so much, Dalton High School athlete Eder Mora has decided to make a sacrifice — giving up football.

    July 26, 2014 2 Photos

  • Whitfield, Chris.JPG Chris Whitfield: Football fans may lose, but Mora will win with decision

    Throughout my career, I have been lucky enough to see some of the finest athletes this state has ever produced. From professional athletes who went on to the NFL, MLB and the NBA to college washouts who still rank as the finest high school athletes I have ever seen, I have been blessed.

    July 26, 2014 1 Photo