State News

October 25, 2013

Lawmakers study tough death penalty provision

ATLANTA — Georgia state lawmakers held a hearing Thursday to gather input from the public on whether changes should be made to a law that requires death penalty defendants to prove beyond a reasonable doubt they are intellectually disabled to be spared execution on those grounds.

Georgia became the first state, in 1988, to ban the execution of the intellectually disabled, and the U.S. Supreme court in 2002 ruled that the execution of intellectually disabled offenders is unconstitutional. But Georgia’s beyond-a-reasonable-doubt burden of proof of that disability is the strictest in the nation. Other states that impose the death penalty have a lower threshold.

Defense attorneys and advocates for the intellectually disabled told the House Judiciary Non-Civil Committee that the standard is too high and will likely result in the execution of some intellectually disabled death row inmates. Prosecutors said they aren’t necessarily opposed to changing the law but said any changes could have unintended consequences.

The fact that Georgia is the only state with such a strict standard means it merits examination, said Rep. Rich Golick, a Republican from Smyrna who chairs the committee. The hearing was a good first step toward learning the facts and issues surrounding a possible change, he said after the meeting, adding that more research and consideration are needed before any decision can be made on possible legislation.

Jack Martin, with the Georgia Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, told the committee he was involved 25 years ago in the drafting of the language of the law at issue. The change was made quickly in the waning days of a legislative session and was not intended to require that intellectual disability had to be proved beyond a reasonable doubt, he said.

“It was sloppy draftsmanship, pure and simple,” he said.

Intellectually disability is already difficult to prove, he said. Defendants must have an IQ of 70 or below, with a flexibility of five points in either direction; have substantial deficits in adaptive behavior; and demonstrate the disability prior to the age of 18. Additionally, conflicting expert testimony at trial can create a reasonable doubt in the mind of a jury, making the burden of proof impossible to meet, he said.

“If it is unconstitutional to execute the mentally retarded.  You can’t create a state procedure that makes it virtually impossible to prove that,” Martin said.

He and others who spoke before the council advocated for the burden of proof to be set at a preponderance of the evidence in death penalty cases and for a separate pretrial hearing to determine whether a defendant is intellectually disabled, rather than having that included in the guilt or innocence phase of a trial that is decided by a jury.

Gwinnett County District Attorney Danny Porter, speaking on behalf of the District Attorneys’ Association, said no prosecutor in the state wants to see an intellectually disabled person executed, but the district attorneys do have some concerns about possible changes.

“We offer caution regarding cracking open a statute that has been litigated, that has been upheld all the way to the United States Supreme Court, has been tested and tried,” Porter said. “We offer caution and we’re prepared to engage in any discussions once a piece of legislation is before us.”

Changing the statute could open the state to a flood of new litigation, Porter said. People who previously wouldn’t have tried to use an intellectual disability defense because they didn’t think they could meet the beyond-a-reasonable-doubt burden of proof might now use it in either old cases or future cases, he said.

Though advocates of changes in the statute have said they want any changes to be narrowly applied only to the burden of proof for death penalty defendants and for it not to be retroactive, Porter said he’s not sure either of those conditions is legally permissible. Any felony criminal defendant can use an intellectual disability defense, meaning that burden of proof would likely also have to apply to defendants in burglary, armed robbery and other felony cases, he said.

Porter also disputed the assertion that conflicting expert testimony could make it impossible for juries to determine intellectual disability beyond a reasonable doubt, arguing that juries are confronted every day with conflicting evidence on facets of a trial that must meet that standard.

 

1
Text Only
State News
  • One charged in death of Dalton woman, another sought

    A Dalton woman found dead in Calhoun earlier this month is believed to have died of a drug overdose after two Calhoun residents abandoned her in a car behind the VFW on East Line Street, Lt. Tony Pyle with the Calhoun Police Department said Wednesday afternoon.

    June 18, 2014

  • Guard shot at FedEx center to undergo 14th surgery

    A security guard critically wounded when a gunman went on a rampage at a FedEx facility is scheduled to undergo his 14th operation Tuesday.

    May 27, 2014

  • Arson ruled out as cause of chemical plant fire

    Police say investigators have been able to rule out arson or foul play as the cause of a massive fire at a chemical plant outside Atlanta that spewed black smoke and flames visible for miles.

    May 27, 2014

  • Teen tied to shopping cart drowns in lake

    Georgia Department of Natural Resources officials say a teen has died after being tied to a shopping cart and pushed into Lake Allatoona.

    May 25, 2014

  • Underground tattoo artists frustrate officials

    The work of tattoo artists whose living rooms double as body art studios might come cheap, but experts say the unsterile -- and illegal -- work environments could leave clients in pain long after the initial sting of the needle subsides.

    May 25, 2014

  • No runoff lets Republicans focus on Rep. Barrow

    While Georgia Republicans have to wait until July to settle runoff races for the U.S. Senate and three open House seats, one of the biggest GOP victories in the primary elections last week went to Augusta businessman Rick W. Allen.

    May 25, 2014

  • Audit probes juvenile justice turnover rate

    A state audit cites low pay, long hours and management concerns as reasons for a relatively high turnover rate at the Georgia Department of Juvenile Justice.

    May 25, 2014

  • Atlanta schools ex-tech director to be sentenced

    After his relationship with the superintendent of Atlanta’s school system soured, a former technology director for the district set up a kickback scheme to pad his pockets before he left his job, according to court documents.

    May 24, 2014

  • Georgia veteran, 92, honored at surprise ceremony

    Family and friends surprised a 92-year-old World War II veteran from Georgia on Memorial Day by honoring him and presenting him with the World War II Victory Medal.

    May 24, 2014

  • Police: Massive chemical plant fire extinguished

    Authorities say a massive fire at a chemical plant outside Atlanta that spewed black smoke and flames visible for miles has been extinguished.

    May 24, 2014